I read an article called 5 Reasons
Most Studies About Violent Video Games are B.S. By: Dan Seitz. In this article it is clear that Dan
is against all the studies done on violent video games. One thing he says that
seeing violence doesn’t not make a person violent. He continues on to say, “Then
there’s the fact that in the U.S the crime
rate peaked in 1991 and has been dropping ever since. Factor in crimes per
capita and it drops like a rock. So,
it’s pretty clear we, as a country, have developed a huge taste for violent
media…but are becoming less violent as a country.” After
looking it up on the FBI UCR Crime Report this is a true statement the crime
rate has dropped drastically from 1991-2010. So that’s one reason on violent
video games making people violent isn’t true. Later on in the article Dan also
claims that research is only focused on video games but it does not compare
video games to other violent media like football, ufc, hockey fights. After I
tried looking it up on Google, LexisNexis, and other Article databases I was
unable to find research on these topics so that’s another good point he made.
So if you want to blame violence on video games to be fair you have to take
into account all other violent media that kids are being exposed to. Dan also states
that research also fails to take into account the home factors in before the
violent video games are introduced and he says, “One
thing psychologists definitely agree on across the board: if you beat up your
kid, or scream at them constantly, or just ignore them, they’re going to have
serious emotional problem.” After I looked up an article on CNN and Palo
Alto Medical Foundation and these two articles did no research what so ever on
the home life of their subjects all they tested was the video games. So if your
not taking into account the other factors you are leaving a lot of information
out making your study incomplete. I was able to find on many articles on
LexisNexis that did support his claim that psychologist do agree that if you
abuse your child they would have emotional problems. Dan Also goes on to
explain that the “studies” to claim this do not say what kind of study was done
or what where the methods used to take the study. I believe this is true I
found many news articles and videos on Fox News, CNN, AZ Republic that all just
state studies they never mention any researchers name or what the study was
called or anything. So I believe Dan has made a very solid argument and I found
that all his major claims were supported by some kind of research because I went
to look up the claims he made and everything was supported. It was all
supported by major credible and widely accepted sources like CNN, Fox News, The
FBI’s UCR, and LexisNexis.
No comments:
Post a Comment